Chaco Rozz Women's Shoes for $39.73. Select in-store pickup at REI to save on shipping.  Otherwise shipping is $5.99 or free for orders over $50.  If needed, use this Filler Tool to qualify for free shipping.  Here is a screenshot for reference. The shoes have 25% recycled rubber EcoTread outsoles, polyurethane midsole, and canvas/suede/mesh upper.